In the end I went with Bennie Moore's Mountain Laurel.
Here's my handy tip for keeping the rim of your paint can tidy while you paint
Then you can just dip and wipe on the band instead of the edge!
2 coats later I had a fresh and fun new door. I need to do a bit of plant trimming/re-arranging out here, but the color sure is fun!
I love the way the color goes with the greige walls and charcoal trim, plus it really makes the hardware pop.
Honestly the color did look a bit darker on the paint chip and I would have liked to have it be a bit darker but
I am really happy with the color as it is. I was a bit worried what my older neighbors would say, but just a few days ago I got a phone call from one of them just to tell me how much they loved the new color! You know you live in a
boring quiet neighborhood when your door is the topic of neighborly conversation!